Water Damage and Recovery: A Homeowners Insurance Journey

Why you can trust Insure.com

Quality Verified

At Insure.com, we are committed to providing the timely, accurate and expert information consumers need to make smart insurance decisions. All our content is written and reviewed by industry professionals and insurance experts. Our team carefully vets our rate data to ensure we only provide reliable and up-to-date insurance pricing. We follow the highest editorial standards. Our content is based solely on objective research and data gathering. We maintain strict editorial independence to ensure unbiased coverage of the insurance industry.

Homeownership is a significant milestone, but it also comes with unexpected challenges. One of the most essential safeguards is homeowners insurance, which provides financial protection when disaster strikes. This case study follows Sam, a mother and a family therapist in South Florida, who encountered a severe water damage issue in her home. Her experience underscores why homeowners insurance is essential and how it works in real-life situations.

The discovery of water damage

Sam first noticed a persistent, musty smell in her home. Concerned, she called a mold inspector, who confirmed the presence of mold in both visible and airborne forms. Further investigation revealed standing water in her kitchen.

Eventually, it was determined that there were two separate leaks: one behind her kitchen sink and another in an adjoining bathroom.

“They had to remove the counters and the walls to find the leak and it ended up being two leaks behind the wall where my kitchen sink was and behind that was my bathroom so they shared plumbing,” Sam said.

Filing an insurance claim

Recognizing the urgency of the situation, Sam filed a homeowners insurance claim within a week of discovering the mold. Since the damage was hidden behind the walls and not due to negligence, her insurance policy covered the claim. Home insurance typically approves claims when the damage is sudden, accidental, and not resulting from long-term neglect.

Understanding coverage: What was and was not paid for

One of the most surprising aspects of Sam’s experience was learning how her homeowners insurance policy worked.

“I didn’t know this part, but they don’t actually pay to fix the problem. They pay to fix the damage,” Sam said. “So they didn’t pay to fix the pipes, actually. They paid for all the damage the leak and mold caused in the house. That’s how it was written.”

But while Sam’s insurance covered the costs associated with repairing the damage, including removing and replacing walls, flooring, and cabinets, it did not pay to repair the leaking pipes.

This meant that while Sam received financial assistance to restore her home, she had to pay to fix the plumbing issue that caused the damage in the first place. She also was responsible for meeting her home insurance policy deductible.

Later, Sam would have to submit proof to the insurer that she had corrected the problem to continue receiving payment for her claim.

Extent of the damage and reimbursement

The water damage extended beyond Sam’s kitchen. Since the affected wall was shared with both her pantry and bathroom, those areas also required extensive repairs. The insurance company covered the costs of replacing the kitchen cabinets, repainting walls, and installing new flooring.

Additionally, because her kitchen and bathroom were unusable during the renovation, her policy also covered the cost of temporary housing. She was reimbursed for three months of rent for a comparable home in her area while construction was underway.

Working with a law firm

Instead of handling the claim process alone, Sam chose to hire a law firm specializing in insurance claims. This decision was driven by two factors:

Guidance: Since she had never filed a claim before, she wanted expert advice on the best course of action.
Fair treatment: Having legal representation ensured her insurance company clearly understood the strength of her claim, as she had professionals effectively presenting her case.

The law firm guided her through the process, but Sam’s family was also enormously helpful. Together, Sam and her mother organized and submitted necessary documents, while her legal support provided peace of mind and helped avoid potential pitfalls.

The timeline of repairs

From filing the claim to moving back into her home, Sam’s journey was anything but quick. The entire process took about six months, highlighting the reality that even with insurance, home restoration can be a long and complex undertaking. Here’s how the timeline played out:

Claim filing: Within a week of discovering the mold.
Leak detection and estimates: Several weeks to pinpoint the exact cause and obtain contractor quotes.
Approval and construction start: Two months before the first construction work began.
Temporary relocation: Three months of living in a rented home.
Final move-in: Approximately six months after the claim was filed.

Even after moving back in, there were still outstanding tasks, such as painting and final reimbursements based on completed work. Insurance companies often release payments in installments, requiring homeowners to submit receipts and proof of completion before issuing the final checks.

Challenges with insurance payments

Although Sam received financial assistance relatively quickly, the initial insurance payout covered only about a third of the total repair costs. This is common, as insurance companies often provide a preliminary estimate that may not fully account for all damages.

Through persistence and documentation of additional costs, Sam secured further reimbursements over time.

Her case highlights an essential lesson for homeowners: Do not accept the first insurance estimate without reviewing the full scope of damage. Homeowners should challenge the initial payout and provide detailed evidence to request additional funds if necessary.

Key takeaways from Sam’s experience

Homeowners insurance is a lifeline: Sam would have faced tens of thousands of dollars in repair costs without insurance. While she had to pay for plumbing repairs, most damage-related expenses were covered, saving her from financial strain.
File claims promptly: Insurance companies may deny claims if they believe homeowners delayed reporting the damage. Sam’s quick action in filing her claim helped ensure she received coverage.
Know what your policy covers: Understanding policy details is crucial. Homeowners should review whether their insurance covers mold, water damage and temporary housing, as not all policies are identical.
Consider professional assistance: Hiring a law firm or a public adjuster can be beneficial, especially for first-time claimants. These professionals help navigate the claims process and can negotiate better settlements.
Prepare for a long process: Even with efficient handling, claims and repairs take time. Homeowners should be prepared for delays, negotiations, and multiple payment installments.

Final thoughts

Sam’s story is a powerful reminder of why homeowners insurance is indispensable. While no one expects to deal with extensive home damage, having the right coverage can make a difference when the unexpected occurs. Her experience serves as both a cautionary tale and a guide for other homeowners, emphasizing the importance of being proactive, informed, and persistent when navigating insurance claims.

For anyone on the fence about homeowners insurance, Sam’s case makes one thing clear: When disaster strikes, having coverage can mean the difference between financial devastation and a manageable recovery.

Zack Sigel

Zack Sigel is a writer and editor based in New York City. He has been managing editor at Policygenius and M1 Finance, where he led teams specialized in writing about business and finance, and he has also written about music and culture for Hyperallergic, VH1, Complex, and the Los Angeles Review of Books. Zack has a bachelor's degree from New York University, Tisch School of the Arts.