Home Insurance Quotes
Should gun owners carry more insurance?
Having a gun in your home can have repercussions for your homeowners insurance, especially the liability portion of your policy, so understanding the various impacts is important.
When it comes to home insurance, most home insurance companies have no issue with gun ownership, and in most cases, the insurer doesn’t even ask about firearms during the application process. However, there can be exceptions. Coverage levels are usually capped, and if you shoot someone -- even an intruder -- you may be on your own.
Insurers aren’t interested in your guns
To an insurance company, guns are simply property. "Home insurance policies typically cover firearms as property in the same way they would cover any other property in your home," says Robert Hartwig, President of the Insurance Information Institute.
"If a firearm were damaged in a fire or stolen, the damage or loss of such property would generally be covered under a standard homeowners policy, subject to any deductible and policy sublimits," continues Hartwig.
Since guns are considered property, they ordinarily have no impact on your rates, and you don't even need to tell your insurer. "Generally speaking, a policyholder does not need to inform their insurer that they own firearms," confirms Hartwig.
Unlike many other forms of insurance that offer discounts in almost every category, discounts on firearms policies do not exist. "For all intents and purposes, there are no discounts or surcharges for having a firearm," says Kristofer Kirchen, with Advanced Insurance Managers in Tampa, Florida.
You might run into insurance sublimits
If you have many guns or are a collector, sublimits can be an issue. Sublimits are dollar-amount limitations in your policy that apply to specific losses. Most insurers consider guns to be valuable property and include them with items such as artwork, jewelry, and furs, all of which are subject to a sublimit. This means that coverage is usually limited to $2,500 for your entire gun collection.
If your gun collection is valued above $2,500, you will need to purchase a rider, an insurance provision that adds more coverage, which will definitely impact your rates.
"Owning guns doesn't automatically affect your insurance rates, but if you do opt to purchase a separate rider, there will be an additional charge," explains Carole Walker with the Rocky Mountain Insurance Information Association. Cost for the additional coverage varies by insurance company, but forum users reported varied levels of rider coverage from $15,000 to $50,000 of replacement coverage for a single annual payment ranging from $50 to $380.
Another option is to purchase a separate, standalone policy to protect your gun collection. ArmsCare Plus, which is endorsed by the National Rifle Association (NRA), offers additional protection for all legal firearms as well as accessories, such as scopes, mounts, and slings. The policy protects against damage, fire, theft, and loss. Coverage is reasonable with $10,000 in replacement value insurance costing less than $110 per year.
Accidents are covered
While damage or theft related to firearms is generally covered by your homeowners policy, liability issues can be a mixed bag – especially if you intentionally pull the trigger.
Accidental shootings are usually covered. However, liability coverage does not include those in your household. In the event you manage to shoot yourself or a member of your household, liability coverage would not apply, and medical bills would fall to the health insurance policy of the person injured.
"If the gun is accidentally discharged, the homeowners insurance policy would typically cover the costs of any resulting property damage, injury, or death to a third party, such as a neighbor or visitor to your house,” says Hartwig
Accidents outside the home, like those that could occur either hunting or at a shooting range, should also be covered by your homeowners policy.
"If you are hunting and fire your gun in a manner where you are trying to hit a deer but miss, that is not an intentional act. You should be covered. The same would apply if you were at a range," says Jonathan Stein, an attorney in Elk Grove, California.
Are these situations covered by homeowners insurance?
|Scenario||Damage to home||Injures or kills person (not a household member)|
|Discharges gun during gun cleaning||Yes||Yes|
|Discharges gun while hunting||N/A||Yes – Did not intend to shoot person|
|Shoots an intruder intentionally||No||No – Intention was to shoot the person|
|Believes to be shooting an intruder, but turns out to be someone else||Yes||Yes – Did not intent to shoot the second person|
|Minor discharges gun accidentally||Yes||Yes|
|Minor discharges gun intentionally||No - Intentional acts by minors who are deemed able to know the different are not covered.||No – Intentional acts by minors who are deemed able to know the difference are not covered.|
This chart is for general reference and not to be used as legal advice. Individual situations are subject to review by insurance company.
Commercial activities, however, are another matter.
"If you were being paid to guide a hunt or teach someone to hunt or shoot at a range then it is a business use, and there is no coverage," advises Stein.
Without a homeowners policy for protection, you would need a business policy that would to cover your needs.
According to Dean Davison with Lockton Companies, expect to pay around $300 a year for a $1 million in liability protection on a professional policy offering the following coverages:
- Injuries and/or damage you cause while acting as an instructor during a lesson
- Medical expenses up to $5,000
- Legal expenses from lawsuits related to injuries or damage
- Professional Liability coverage that protects you from allegations of negligent training
Exceptions to coverage
While a genuine accident would be covered, there can be exceptions. If alcohol or drugs are involved when the accident occurs, depending on local laws, you may be on the hook for damages.
"While coverage may apply in some circumstances, the outcome could vary depending on the specific circumstances of the claim and applicable state and local laws," warns Hartwig.
In many states, leaving a loaded weapon in the open where a child can access it is a crime, and the gun owner would be responsible for the cost of damages should the child intentionally hurt someone with it.
Also, if you are in the middle of committing a crime when an accidental shooting occurs, all hope of insurance coverage is gone, since intentional and criminal acts are excluded from coverage.
Plan on purchasing additional liability coverage
If an accidental shooting occurs with one of your weapons, you could be on the losing end of a wrongful death lawsuit. Attorney fees, damages, and medical bills could quickly exceed a low-limit liability policy included in homeowners insurance. Settlements in excess of $1 million are not uncommon.
Liability limits start at $100,000 on a standard homeowners policy, but most experts recommend that policyholders carry at least $300,000. Gun owners should consider carrying even more, or look at an umbrella policy.
Umbrella policies are usually sold in $1 million dollar increments and are fairly affordable. According to the Insurance Information Institute, umbrella policies cost about $150 to $300 per year for a $1 million, the next million would cost roughly $75, and then $50 for each additional million.
Intentional shootings are not covered by homeowners insurance
Accidental shootings are actually pretty rare. According to the Center for Disease Control and Prevention, in 2013, there were 505 deaths caused by the accidental discharge of a firearm. That translates into 1.5 percent of all firearm-related deaths that year. That means most people are intentionally pulling the trigger, and if that is the case – even if you believe your family is in danger – it can have serious repercussions.
Homeowner policies have "intentional injury exclusions,” which means if you intentionally cause damage or harm, you are on your own in any resulting liability claims.
"All policies deny coverage for intentional injuries," explains Thomas Simeone, with Simeone & Miller LLP. "So, if you shoot at and strike an intruder, there will likely be no coverage because you intended to injure them. It does not matter whether the shooting was justified or not. However, if you accidentally shoot someone, there will be coverage because you did not intend to injure that person," continues Simeone.
This means that if you intentionally shoot a burglar or anyone else, and they sue you, the cost of your defense, and any resulting award to that person would fall to you, which can quickly become very expensive.
Added protection for self-defense
A standalone self-defense policy can step into the breach for intentional injuries. "The primary benefit of a self-defense policy is that it provides coverage for acts of self-defense that are generally not covered by homeowners/renters insurance policies," explains Jeff Hewitt, a senior vice president with Lockton Affinity.
"It fills the void that is left in homeowners or renters policies, which usually classify an act of self-defense as an intentional act," continues Hewitt.
For example, policies at mynrainsurance.com provide coverage starting at $100,000 for combined single limit with a $50,000 criminal defense reimbursement sublimit for $165 per year.
According to Hewitt, the following are major benefits of a self-defense policy:
- Protects you for using your legally owned firearm, with or without a concealed carry permit
- Reimburses you for criminal defense costs related to self-defense, if acquitted
- Covers your defense and damages in a civil suit
- Includes Bodily Injury or Property Damage coverage
The best way to avoid a liability claim is to make sure your weapons are properly stored and handled, but additional coverage could be a financial lifesaver if the unthinkable were to happen.
More from Mark Vallet here