How much car insurance costs in Florida vs. New York

Why you can trust Insure.com

Quality Verified

At Insure.com, we are committed to providing the timely, accurate and expert information consumers need to make smart insurance decisions. All our content is written and reviewed by industry professionals and insurance experts. Our team carefully vets our rate data to ensure we only provide reliable and up-to-date insurance pricing. We follow the highest editorial standards. Our content is based solely on objective research and data gathering. We maintain strict editorial independence to ensure unbiased coverage of the insurance industry.

Car insurance rates vary significantly depending on where you live. Insurance premiums in Florida and New York differ widely due to state laws, traffic conditions and weather events, among other factors.

For instance, policyholders in Florida pay $224 a month for car insurance, while premiums for the same coverage in New York are $156 per month, according to a data study by Insure.com.

Whether you’re moving from one state to another or simply curious about how your location impacts your premiums, understanding the difference in auto insurance rates can help you make informed decisions.

This guide provides a detailed comparison of car insurance rates between Florida and New York and outlines the key factors influencing insurance premiums.

Average car insurance rates in Florida vs. New York

In Florida, the average monthly car insurance premium is $224, while in New York, it’s $156. For a 6-month policy, drivers in Florida typically pay $1,347, while New York drivers pay an average of $935.

Policyholders in New York typically face lower car insurance premiums than those in Florida. These differences are primarily driven by factors such as population density, weather patterns and state laws. However, individual rates vary depending on factors such as driving history, age, coverage limits, and ZIP code.

Below is an overview of average car insurance rates in Florida and New York.

Learn more about average monthly car insurance rates.

Florida vs. New York: Rates by different coverage levels

If you compare car insurance rates between Florida and New York, the cost will vary significantly depending on the type of coverage you choose. The annual rate in Florida is $2,694 for full coverage, whereas in New York, it is slightly lower at $1,870. This difference reflects the varying risk factors and market conditions in both states.

Car insurance rates vary by coverage level because the more protection a policy provides, the higher the cost. Full coverage, which includes liability, comprehensive and collision coverage, is more expensive than basic liability-only insurance, which covers only damages to other driver’s vehicles and their injuries in an at-fault accident.

Below are the car insurance rates in Florida and New York for various coverage levels and types.

Cheapest car insurance providers: Florida vs. New York

Car insurance rates differ in Florida and New York due to differences in state laws, risk factors, population density, traffic patterns, weather risks and repair costs, all of which contribute to the cost of coverage.

States with higher accident rates or natural disasters may have higher premiums, while those with more competition among insurers may see lower rates. The frequency and severity of claims, along with state-specific laws and discount programs, also influence the rates insurance companies offer.

Cheapest car insurance providers in Florida

State Farm offers the cheapest car insurance in Florida at $2,119 a year on average followed by Nationwide at $2,150 and GEICO at $2,214 a year.

The table below shows car insurance providers in Florida with affordable car insurance rates.

Cheapest car insurance providers in New York

Progressive has the cheapest car insurance rates in New York with an average annual cost of $1,020. NYCM Insurance and GEICO also have affordable rates, at $1,300 and $1,736 respectively.

Below, you see car insurance providers with affordable rates for drivers in New York.

Car insurance cost in Florida and New York by ZIP code

Car insurance rates aren’t the same everywhere—your ZIP code comes into play. Even within the same state, your rates can vary significantly depending on your location.

Here’s a quick comparison of car insurance costs in Florida and New York.

Car insurance cost in Florida by ZIP code

If you’re in Florida, you might be paying more or less for your car insurance based on your ZIP code. For instance, the 34953 ZIP code has the cheapest car insurance rates in Florida, among the top 10 most populous ZIP codes analyzed, with an average annual cost of $2,696.

Insurance companies also factor in the crime rates of a specific area, especially the frequency of car theft and vandalism. If a ZIP code has a higher rate of stolen vehicles or accidents, you might end up paying a bit more for coverage.

Car insurance cost in New York by ZIP code

Car insurance rates in New York vary by ZIP code due to population density, traffic and crime rates. For example, among the top 10 most populous ZIP codes, the average annual rate in ZIP code 11236 is $2,948, while in ZIP 10025, it’s lower at $2,397.

Areas with more traffic and higher crime rates tend to have higher premiums. To save on insurance, consider shopping around, raising your deductible and looking for discounts like safe driving or bundling policies.

Top car insurance providers: Florida vs New York

Shopping for car insurance can be overwhelming, especially when you have so many options. Insurance rates vary from state to state based on a number of factors, such as driving habits, accident rates and insurance laws. Below, we’ll compare car insurance rates from top car insurance companies in New York and Florida.

Top car insurance companies in Florida

State Farm tops the list with an overall ranking of 4.64 and a customer satisfaction score of 0.79. It’s a great option if you’re looking for an insurer with good customer service.

GEICO follows closely with a ranking of 4.39 and a customer satisfaction score of 0.69.

The table below highlights the top car insurance providers in the state, ranking them based on overall performance and customer satisfaction.

Top car insurance companies in New York

NYCM Insurance leads with an overall ranking of 4.56 and a customer satisfaction rating of 0.03, closely followed by State Farm at 4.08 with a satisfaction rating of 0.79. GEICO comes next with a ranking of 4.03 and a satisfaction score of 0.69.

When choosing an insurance provider, it’s important to consider the customer satisfaction rating. This rating reflects how well the company treats its policyholders, handles claims, and responds to customer concerns.

Comparing car insurance requirements in Florida and New York

Florida and New York laws require drivers to carry minimum liability car insurance coverage to drive on the road legally. However, the specific coverage requirements vary between the two states. Below is a detailed comparison of the minimum car insurance requirements in Florida and New York:

Read more about minimum car insurance requirements by state.

Shivani Gite

Contributing Writer

 

|

 . .

Shivani Gite is a personal finance and insurance writer with a degree in journalism and mass communication. She is passionate about making insurance topics easy to understand for people and helping them make better financial decisions.