How to Choose an Insurance Company: Ratings, Complaints & More

Why you can trust Insure.com

Quality Verified

At Insure.com, we are committed to providing the timely, accurate and expert information consumers need to make smart insurance decisions. All our content is written and reviewed by industry professionals and insurance experts. Our team carefully vets our rate data to ensure we only provide reliable and up-to-date insurance pricing. We follow the highest editorial standards. Our content is based solely on objective research and data gathering. We maintain strict editorial independence to ensure unbiased coverage of the insurance industry.

Choosing the right insurance company takes more than comparing prices — it means evaluating financial strength, claims reliability, and customer satisfaction. By using publicly available data and independent ratings, you can find insurers that deliver consistent protection and long-term stability, not just short-term savings.

A thorough online investigation reveals how insurers handle claims, respond to crises, and treat policyholders over time. Experts warn that low premiums can mask poor service or weak coverage, making research essential before you commit to any policy.

“We want people to investigate who has the best quality protection for the best prices and who has the best reputation for consumer service and satisfaction. If the price seems too good to be true, it probably is,” says Amy Bach, executive director of the United Policyholders consumer group.

⚠️ The 5-minute check that could save you thousands later

Before choosing an insurer, take a few minutes to verify what really matters:

Financial stability. Will they actually be around to pay claims years from now?
Lawsuits and disputes. Are customers regularly suing to get paid?
Complaint trends. Is poor service a pattern or an exception?
Claims handling reputation. Do they pay quickly or fight every claim?
Regulatory actions. Has the state pursued enforcement against them?

Don’t let ads or low prices make the decision for you. Insurers highlight their strengths but rarely reveal how they handle claims or complaints. Skipping these steps can leave you underprotected when it matters most.

How do you check your state insurance department?

Your state insurance department’s website is the best place to start when researching any insurer. It provides verified, state-regulated data on complaint ratios, licensing details, rate filings, and enforcement actions — information you won’t find through marketing materials or insurer websites.

The Department of Insurance (DOI) is a state-level regulatory agency that oversees insurers and protects consumers. It provides public access to:

Complaint records that show how often customers report issues
Licensing status confirming the insurer is authorized to sell policies in your state
Disciplinary actions taken against insurers for misconduct
Market conduct reports that reveal how insurers operate behind the scenes
Enforcement actions that show whether an insurer consistently meets consumer protection standards

These records help you quickly spot patterns of poor service or repeated violations that should make you think twice.

💡 Why a few minutes of research can save you for decades

Researching insurance companies isn’t about finding the cheapest policy — it’s about finding one that will still be there when you need it. If you’re buying life insurance to protect your kids, you need confidence the insurer will be around 30 or 40 years from now.

A cheap policy from a financially weak company can leave your family with nothing if the insurer fails or fights every claim. Spending 15 minutes checking financial ratings and complaint data can save you from making one of the most expensive mistakes of your financial life.

Where can you find an insurer’s financial strength ratings?

Independent rating agencies like Standard & Poor’s (S&P) and A.M. Best publish financial strength ratings that tell you whether a company has the financial backing to pay claims now and decades from now. These are the most reliable indicators of an insurer’s long-term stability.

Standard & Poor’s (S&P) is an independent financial rating agency that evaluates insurers based on their ability to meet financial obligations:

AAA — Highest rating, exceptional financial strength
AA — Very strong financial strength
A — Strong financial strength
BBB — Adequate, but proceed with some caution
BB or lower — Financially weaker, higher risk of claim issues

A.M. Best is a credit rating agency focused specifically on the insurance industry. It evaluates insurers on financial strength, operating performance, and overall business profile to assess how reliably an insurer can pay claims.

You can also check both ratings on platforms like Insure.com to compare companies side by side.

💡 A strong rating is more than a stamp of approval

A high financial strength rating means the insurer can actually support you when you need to file a claim, even years from now. It’s not just a marketing badge — it’s the difference between an insurer that pays out reliably and one that may struggle to honor claims during a major disaster or economic downturn.

How can you find lawsuits against an insurance company?

You can find lawsuits against an insurance company by searching PACER for federal cases and your state’s court website for local disputes. A few lawsuits are normal for any large insurer, but repeated legal disputes can reveal deeper problems with how a company handles claims.

Here’s where to look:

PACER (Public Access to Court Electronic Records). The U.S. courts’ online database for searching federal lawsuits involving insurers. Access costs about 10 cents per page.
Your state court system. Many states provide free online access to local lawsuits, which can reveal disputes that don’t appear in federal records.
State Department of Insurance. Often lists enforcement actions and regulatory disputes that may not have escalated to lawsuits.
State Attorney General’s office. Publicly tracks legal actions taken against insurers for unfair practices.

Steven Rambam, a private investigator with over 30 years of experience and director of Pallorium Inc., recommends starting with PACER to identify cases where claims were denied or mishandled. After reviewing federal cases, check your state’s court system for additional disputes that may not appear at the federal level.

💡 What lawsuits can reveal about an insurer

A handful of lawsuits against a major insurer is normal — they handle millions of claims and disputes are inevitable. But if you see the same complaint pattern over and over (delayed payments, denied claims for covered events, lowball settlement offers), that’s a red flag that the insurer may not honor claims without a fight. Look for repeated themes, not isolated incidents.

What to read next

10 dirty little secrets of insurance companies

How to give a car as a gift -- and keep it a secret

10 things that are illegal but shouldn’t be

The states with the rudest drivers – and the states that hate them

Cars that attract the ladies (and guys)

Our agents make it hassle-free to get the right quote.

Call (844) 814-8854

Ethan Available Now

Jack Available Now

Robbie Available Now

Ellie Available Now

What do customer satisfaction ratings reveal?

Customer satisfaction ratings show how real policyholders feel about their insurance company — especially when it comes to claims handling, customer service, and overall value. These ratings help you see which insurers actually follow through on their promises, not just market them well.

According to Insure.com (2026), customer satisfaction ratings are based on five key factors that reflect real-world experience:

How smoothly claims are handled. Speed, fairness, and ease of the process
Quality and responsiveness of customer service. How easy it is to get help when you need it
Overall value for the price you pay. Whether the coverage matches the cost
Whether customers would recommend the insurer. A strong indicator of trust
Whether policyholders plan to renew. The clearest signal of real satisfaction

These metrics give you a practical, real-world view of how insurers treat policyholders — making them one of the most useful tools for choosing a reliable company.

What are complaint sites and should you trust them?

Complaint sites are online platforms where frustrated customers share complaints about companies, often focused on bad experiences like denied claims or poor service. They can highlight real issues, but treat them as starting points for research — not definitive proof.

Because most posts come from unhappy customers, the information can be one-sided or incomplete. Pay attention to repeated patterns rather than isolated complaints, since recurring themes can signal deeper problems with how an insurer operates.

When you come across a complaint, dig a little deeper before drawing conclusions:

Check if similar issues appear across multiple sites. Repetition suggests a pattern, not a one-off
Look for specific details. See if you see a trend of denied claims, delays, or settlement disputes
Verify whether the complaint was filed with the state DOI. Formal complaints carry more weight
See if the issue escalated into a lawsuit. The strongest signal of a serious dispute

💡 How to read between the lines on complaint sites

Rage sites are biased toward unhappy customers — happy ones rarely post — so use them to spot patterns, not to make final judgments. If you see the same issue repeated across multiple sources (slow claim payments, denied weather damage, low-balled estimates), it may point to a real problem with how the insurer handles claims. When possible, cross-check complaints with state DOI records or court filings to see if the issue is documented officially.

How do state attorneys general protect insurance consumers?

State attorneys general protect consumers by taking legal action against insurance companies for unfair practices, challenging unjustified rate increases, and publicizing enforcement actions on their official websites. Their offices are one of the most underused resources for spotting insurers under regulatory scrutiny.

Here’s how AG offices work to protect insurance consumers:

Filing lawsuits against insurers for unfair claims practices, deceptive marketing, or bad-faith denials
Opposing rate increases that regulators consider unjustified or excessive
Investigating consumer complaints that suggest broader patterns of misconduct
Publishing enforcement actions so the public can see which insurers have faced legal challenges
Coordinating with state DOIs to pursue insurers that violate consumer protection laws

Because attorneys general are elected officials, they tend to publicize their actions widely. According to investigator Steven Rambam, when an AG’s office pursues a case, they usually release detailed updates explaining the issue and outcome — making their websites a strong place to spot insurers facing recent investigations, penalties, or public opposition.

💡 An AG investigation is a serious red flag

If an insurer is being challenged by a state attorney general, it’s a strong signal to look more closely before trusting them with your coverage. AGs don’t pursue cases lightly — by the time an investigation goes public, there’s usually significant evidence of consumer harm. A single AG action may not disqualify an insurer, but it should prompt deeper research before committing.

Tools for investigating insurers at a glance

The seven best resources for researching an insurance company are your state Department of Insurance, S&P Ratings, A.M. Best Ratings, PACER, local court records, customer satisfaction ratings, and your state Attorney General’s office. Each tool reveals a different layer of how an insurer actually performs — from financial stability to claims handling to legal disputes. Using them together gives you a complete picture that no single source can provide.

Investigation tool	What it reveals	Where to find it
State Dept. of Insurance	Complaint ratios, rate hikes, market conduct	Your state’s official DOI website
S&P Ratings	Global financial stability and creditworthiness	S&P ratings
A.M. Best Ratings	Insurance-specific financial strength and performance	A.M. Best website
PACER System	Federal lawsuits filed by consumers against insurers	PACER.gov
Local Court Records	State-level lawsuits and contract disputes	State Superior/Supreme Court sites
Satisfaction Ratings	Real consumer feedback on claims and service	Insure.com Best Insurance Companies
State Attorney General	Major enforcement actions and rate hike oppositions	Your state’s official AG website

What should you keep in mind before choosing an insurance company?

Choosing an insurance company isn’t just about finding the lowest price — it’s about making sure the provider can support you when you need to file a claim, whether that’s next year or decades from now.

By checking financial ratings, complaint records, lawsuits, and customer feedback, you get a more complete picture of how an insurer actually performs. Each step helps you move beyond marketing claims and focus on real-world reliability.

💡 The cheapest insurer isn’t the best — make sure to compare

The right insurance company combines fair pricing with strong financial stability and a proven track record of treating customers well. A bargain policy from a poorly-rated insurer can cost you everything when you actually need to file a claim, while overpaying for a name-brand company doesn’t guarantee better service. Use all six investigation tools together — no single one tells the full story.

Frequently asked questions

What should you do to research reputable insurance companies?

Start by checking financial strength ratings from agencies like S&P and A.M. Best, then review complaint data from your state insurance department. Look into customer satisfaction ratings, search for lawsuits on PACER, and scan complaint sites for patterns. Using multiple sources gives you a clear picture of how reliable an insurer really is.

Where can you check complaints against an insurance company?

Check your state insurance department’s website, which publishes complaint ratios and enforcement actions. This shows you how often customers report issues with a specific insurer compared to others of similar size.

How often should you review your insurance company?

Review your insurance company at least once a year or before renewing your policy. This helps ensure your provider still offers strong coverage, fair pricing, and reliable service — and gives you the chance to switch if things have changed.

Are financial strength ratings really that important?

Yes — especially for life insurance and long-term policies. A financial strength rating tells you whether the insurer will be able to pay claims years or decades from now. For short-term policies like auto or renters insurance, ratings still matter but are less critical than for policies you’ll hold for a lifetime.

Should I avoid an insurer with any lawsuits or complaints?

No — every major insurer has some lawsuits and complaints simply because they handle millions of policies. What matters is the pattern. A company with a few isolated disputes is normal, but one with recurring complaints about the same issues (denied claims, delayed payments) is a red flag.

Alisha Ambre

Alisha Ambre holds a Bachelor of Arts with honours in English Literature and Media Studies. She focuses on crafting clear, engaging content that makes complex information feel practical and approachable for everyday readers. When she’s not writing, she’s likely on the volleyball court or immersed in a good video game.

On this page

How do you check your state insurance department?
Where can you find an insurer's financial strength ratings?
How can you find lawsuits against an insurance company?
What do customer satisfaction ratings reveal?
What are complaint sites and should you trust them?
How do state attorneys general protect insurance consumers?
Tools for investigating insurers at a glance
What should you keep in mind before choosing an insurance company?
Frequently asked questions

How to choose the right insurance company