Homeowners insurance for first-time buyers: What you really need

For most first-time buyers, homeowners insurance isn’t really a choice — your lender will almost always want proof of coverage before closing on your mortgage. It’s their way of making sure the home (and their investment) is protected if something goes wrong. It also protects you, so you’re not left covering the full cost of repairs or rebuilding after a disaster. Without it, the financial risk for both you and your lender is simply too great.

But homeowners insurance isn’t just about checking a box for your lender. It’s a safety net for you, your home, and everything in it. It can help you recover from damage caused by fire, theft, or severe weather, and it also includes liability coverage if someone gets hurt on your property. Many policies even cover temporary living expenses if your home becomes unlivable, so you can focus on getting back on your feet without the added stress of unexpected costs.

What a standard homeowners insurance policy covers

A standard homeowners policy includes “dwelling coverage,” which protects your home’s structure. If a covered disaster damages your house, this coverage helps pay for repairs or even a full rebuild. It also comes with personal property coverage, which protects your belongings — like furniture, clothing, and electronics — whether they’re damaged at home or stolen while you’re away.

Homeowners insurance also provides liability coverage, which can help cover legal and medical costs if someone gets hurt on your property or if you accidentally damage someone else’s. Most policies also include additional living expenses coverage — this helps pay for things like hotel stays, meals, and other costs if you need to temporarily live elsewhere while your home is being repaired.

What isn’t covered by homeowners insurance

Homeowners insurance doesn’t cover all damage. Floods and earthquakes, for example, require separate policies, which are especially important if you live in a high-risk area. Damage from gradual wear and tear or neglect is also excluded, meaning you’re responsible for routine maintenance and repairs.

Other exclusions often include pest infestations and mold unless they result from a covered event. High-value possessions like jewelry or art may not be fully covered under a standard policy or be subject to sublimits, so you may need to purchase extra coverage or endorsements for complete protection. Understanding these gaps can prevent unpleasant surprises later.

How much homeowners insurance do you need as a first-time buyer?

At a minimum, your policy should provide enough dwelling coverage to completely rebuild your home, not just match what you paid for it. After a major loss, construction costs — including labor, materials, permits, and code upgrades — can easily exceed your home’s market value, especially if prices have risen since you bought it. Getting a rebuild estimate from your insurer or a local contractor can give you a more accurate number.

You’ll also want enough coverage for your personal belongings and liability protection. If you own high-value items like jewelry, art, or collectibles, consider adding riders or endorsements so they’re fully protected. And don’t forget that rebuilding and replacement costs can increase over time — reviewing your coverage regularly can help ensure you won’t be left paying out of pocket for a major loss, even if it means slightly higher premiums for more protection.

What lenders require from your insurance policy

Your lender will usually want to be listed on your homeowners insurance policy. That way, if your home is damaged and the insurance company pays out, the lender can get the money needed to protect their loan. They may also require you to have a certain amount of dwelling coverage — often equal to or more than what you still owe on your mortgage.

Lenders “normally require a policy which covers the full replacement value of the home,” says Rami Sneineh, vice president and licensed insurance producer at Insurance Navy. “This becomes particularly vital in case of any disaster or loss since it means that the property can be restored or reconstructed without any strain on the finances.”

And if you live in an area prone to natural disasters, you may need to purchase additional coverage beyond your homeowners insurance policy. 

“Flood or earthquake coverage is also mandatory depending on the location, especially where there are susceptible areas to natural disasters,” Sneineh says.

Some lenders also place limits on deductibles, preventing you from choosing one that is too high. These requirements are designed to ensure the property — and their investment — is always adequately insured. Meeting them from the start will help your mortgage process move smoothly.

How much does homeowners insurance cost for first-time buyers?

Homeowners pay an average of $2,601 per year for coverage, but your actual rate will depend on your own personal factors, such as your home’s location, its age, construction type, the deductible you choose, and even your credit score.

Where you live plays a big role in how much you pay. Homes in areas prone to hurricanes, wildfires, hail, or frequent storms — like coastal Florida or parts of the Midwest — often have higher premiums. By contrast, properties in communities with strict building codes and strong fire or emergency services may qualify for lower rates.

Your credit-based insurance score, claims history, and deductible choice can also make a big difference. A lower score could mean paying significantly more each year, while a higher deductible can lower your premium — though it also means paying more out of pocket if you have to file a claim.

You can often lower your premium by bundling your home and auto policies, installing smart home devices that enhance security, or filing fewer claims (or none at all). Comparing quotes from multiple insurers can also help you find the best coverage at a competitive rate.

When to get homeowners insurance during the mortgage process

You should secure coverage once you’re under contract, rather than waiting until just before closing. Most lenders require proof of insurance before finalizing your mortgage, and delays in providing it can push back your closing date. You’ll usually prepay your first year’s premium at closing through an escrow account.

“When purchasing a home as a first-time buyer, it is essential to initiate the insurance process early enough during the process of home buying,” says Sneineh. 

“The moment you enter an offer on property, you need to start searching homeowners insurance immediately. Proof of insurance will be necessary before lenders will give you a final approval of the home so it is best to have a policy in effect a few weeks before your closing date.”

What happens if you don’t get homeowners insurance before closing?

If you don’t have homeowners insurance in place by your closing date, your mortgage could be delayed or even fall through completely. Without proof of coverage, lenders won’t release the funds — which could cause you to lose your locked-in interest rate, push back your move-in date, or, in the worst case, cost you the chance to buy the home at all.

In some cases, your lender may step in and arrange what’s called force-placed insurance. This is typically far more expensive than a standard policy and offers only limited protection. Its main purpose is to protect the lender’s financial interest in the property — it usually doesn’t cover your belongings, liability, or additional living expenses if you can’t stay in the home. That means you could still face major out-of-pocket costs after a disaster. For that reason, securing your own comprehensive policy before closing is almost always the smarter and more affordable choice.

Common mistakes first-time buyers make when buying homeowners insurance

When you’re shopping for homeowners insurance, it’s easy to miss a few key details that can leave you less protected than you think. Here are some common things people overlook — and how you can avoid them:

• Mixing up market value and rebuild cost. Your coverage should be based on what it would cost to rebuild your home from the ground up, not what you paid for it. That number is often higher than the purchase price.
• Going for the cheapest policy without looking at what’s inside. A low premium isn’t much help if the coverage leaves big gaps. Compare policies to make sure you’re getting solid protection for the price.
• Forgetting about high-value items. Jewelry, art, and high-end electronics often need extra coverage. Add them to your policy so you’re not paying out of pocket if something happens.
• Not double-checking your lender’s requirements. If your policy doesn’t meet their terms, it could delay your closing. Make sure it’s all squared away ahead of time.

Tips for buying homeowners insurance for the first time

Here’s how to lock in the right homeowners policy before closing:

• Shop around. Compare quotes from multiple insurers to find the best balance of coverage and price. You can work directly with an agent or use an online marketplace to save time and see more options.
• Look into add-ons. Ask about endorsements like sewer backup coverage, which protects against certain water damage not covered by a standard policy, or extended replacement cost, which helps cover rebuilding costs that go beyond your dwelling limit.
• Bundle for savings. Pair your homeowners policy with auto insurance to get a discount from many carriers.
• Loop in your lender early. Share your insurer’s contact information as soon as you have it to avoid delays at closing.

Related Articles