Home Insurance Average home insurance rates for recommended coverage Written by: Les Masterson Les Masterson Les, a former managing editor, insurance, at QuinStreet, has more than 20 years of experience in journalism. In his career, he has covered everything from health insurance to presidential politics. | Reviewed by: Penny Gusner Penny Gusner Penny is an expert on insurance procedures, rates, policies and claims. She has extensive knowledge of all major insurance lines -- auto, homeowners, life and health insurance. She has been answering consumers’ questions as an analyst for more than 15 years and has been featured in numerous major media outlets, including the Washington Post and Kiplinger’s. | Updated on July 15, 2019 Why you can trust Insure.com Quality Verified At Insure.com, we are committed to providing honest and reliable information so that you can make the best financial decisions for you and your family. All of our content is written and reviewed by industry professionals and insurance experts. We maintain strict editorial independence from insurance companies to maintain our editorial integrity, so our recommendations are unbiased and are based on a comprehensive list of criteria. Making sure you have enough home insurance coverage is a vital part of homeownership. Sure, homeowners would much rather think about redecorating a room or paint colors. But home insurance can be the difference between you being able to rebuild your home if the unthinkable happens or facing financial ruin. Homeowners insurance rates vary depending on multiple factors, including the size of the home, the building materials and location. Insure.com recently commissioned Quadrant Information Systems to get home insurance rates for major insurers to find the average premiums by state. We ran the numbers by state to cover a $300,000 dwelling. The policy would include a $1,000 deductible and $300,000 liability coverage since insurance experts usually recommend that level. Average home insurance rates by state for recommended coverage level To see rates, enter your state in the search box. State Average annual rate Florida $5,207 Louisiana $4,474 Oklahoma $3,599 Alabama $3,383 Mississippi $3,316 Arkansas $3,040 Kansas $2,606 Texas $2,599 Missouri $2,392 Tennessee $2,142 Nebraska $2,123 South Carolina $2,110 South Dakota $1,946 Rhode Island $1,942 Colorado $1,904 Kentucky $1,884 West Virginia $1,877 North Dakota $1,850 Minnesota $1,776 Iowa $1,661 Indiana $1,630 New Mexico $1,630 Georgia $1,601 Massachusetts $1,599 Montana $1,594 Michigan $1,533 New York $1,429 Wyoming $1,412 Illinois $1,406 Virginia $1,389 Connecticut $1,323 Alaska $1,256 Maryland $1,231 California $1,200 Ohio $1,186 Pennsylvania $1,184 North Carolina $1,174 Wisconsin $1,110 Arizona $1,081 DC $1,017 New Jersey $1,012 Delaware $1,003 Maine $989 Nevada $957 New Hampshire $939 Washington $896 Oregon $892 Utah $879 Idaho $856 Vermont $816 Hawaii $510 As you can see, average Floridian homeowners pay $4,700 more than Hawaii homeowners. Why does Florida pay such high rates? Let’s dive in. Most expensive states with home insurance rates for recommended coverage level Florida — $5,207 Louisiana — $4,474 Oklahoma — $3,599 Alabama — $3,383 Mississippi — $3,316 Least expensive states with home insurance rates for recommended coverage level Hawaii — $510 Vermont — $816 Idaho — $856 Utah — $879 Oregon — $892 Home insurance rates for recommended coverage level by deductible amount One decision you make when getting a home insurance policy is the deductible. The deductible is what you pay if you file a claim. If your home suffers $10,000 worth of damage and your deductible is $1,000, your insurance company would pay $9,000 for the loss. You would have to pick up the rest. Deductibles affect your insurance premiums. Choosing a $1,000 deductible will result in lower premiums than if you went with a $500 deductible for the same policy. Here’s how the average costs differ for $300,000 dwelling coverage with $300,000 liability coverage: $500 deductible: $1,866 $1,000 deductible: $1,737 $1,500 deductible: $1,667 $2,000 deductible: $1,566 $2,500 deductible: $1,545 It’s wise to choose a deductible that you can afford if you file a claim, but don’t have it so low that you would pay more for premiums. Why is home insurance so expensive in some states? Home insurance companies base their rates on risk. That includes the risk of the specific home and the area. When creating rates, insurers review claims for the geographic area. Places with more claims have higher rates. For instance, let’s say you live in Florida near the ocean. Hurricanes have battered your area and you’ve needed to file a claim. In that case, your insurance rates will be higher than a community that’s away from the coast and especially in a part of the country that doesn’t get severe weather. Insurance companies drill down to look at claims activity by ZIP code and even at the neighborhood level. So, yes, your neighbors’ claim history plays a part in your homeowners’ insurance rates. It’s all about risk. Multiple claims in a neighborhood for fires, burglaries and vandalism will make an insurer think your area is high risk. This is true for high-crime areas. It’s also the case for places without full-time firefighters or nearby fire hydrants. That all factors into your premiums. We found that not living within five miles of a fire station increases your rates by 3% on average. However, those that live much closer to a central fire station may be eligible of a home insurance discount. We found homeowners receive an average discount of 4% for living near a fire station and 3% for living near a police station. All of these factors also play a role in state-wide rates. Florida and Louisiana, which we found have the highest rates, are on the frontlines during hurricane season. That increases an area’s insurance rates. On the other side, those with the lowest home insurance rates are places that don’t usually get hit with major storms, so their rates are lowest. Of course, storm damage is just one factor for insurance rates. Major forest fires that spread to homes could also cause spikes in homeowners insurance rates. The riskier your home is to catastrophe, the higher your insurance rates. What home insurance covers Home insurance is usually broken down into five categories: Dwelling, personal property, loss of use, liability and other structures. Dwelling covers your home if a covered peril, such as fire and vandalism, damages it. Personal property covers your possessions. That includes furniture, electronics and clothing. The coverage is usually between 50 percent and 70 percent of your home’s worth. You can get more coverage if you need it. Loss of use assists you with living expenses if you need to vacate your home if it’s damaged and being repaired or rebuilt. Liability covers you if someone files a claim or sues you or a family member living with you. Other structures covers the detached structures on your property, such as a shed, garage and fence. Recommended home insurance levels Having home insurance is an essential part of homeownership, but you need to make sure you’re covered adequately. Unlike auto insurance, states don’t mandate that everyone have home insurance or require minimum levels of coverage. It’s still critical that you’re covered and have enough insurance in case the unthinkable happens. One common mistake is not having enough liability insurance. Liability coverage often starts at $100,000, but that’s usually not enough. That’s because your home is likely your greatest asset. Liability is the part of the policy that protects you if you’re sued or have a claim filed against you for bodily injury or property damage inflicted by you or a family member living with you. If you’re sued, the plaintiff may go after your house. If you don’t have enough liability insurance, you could lose your home. Insurance experts recommend at least $300,000 worth of liability insurance. Liability insurance goes up to $500,000. How much you actually need depends on your assets. If you have multiple homes in high-priced areas, you may need at least $500,000. You can get umbrella insurance if $500,000 isn’t enough protection. Umbrella insurance offers coverage of up to $5 million. Beyond liability coverage, another vital decision is whether you decide to get replacement value or actual cash value if your home is destroyed. Replacement value provides you the money you need to replace your current home. Actual cash value pays you what your home is currently worth. If your home is 50 years old, the insurer would pay you for a 50-year-old home. Not what it would cost to replace that home. Replacement value, which experts recommend, is more expensive. It’s based roughly on a formula that takes into account a home’s square footage and multiplying that by the cost to rebuild. Building costs vary by area, so you need to get your local building costs to figure out replacement value. A home in a low-value area will have lower per square foot building costs than one in a high-value area. You can get the specifics for your area from your realtor, a local builders’ association, a reputable builder or your insurance company or agent. Make sure to use local numbers and not the national average. Using the national average could mean you have too much coverage (and higher premiums than you need) or not enough coverage. Now, let’s go over an example. Let’s say your local building costs are $100 per square feet. Your home is 2,500 square feet. You multiply the two and your estimated replacement cost would be $250,000. That’s only an estimate. More plays into replacement cost, including the number of rooms and special features, such as garages and fireplaces. If your home has five fireplaces, replacing your home will cost more than a similar house with no fireplaces. Work with your insurance company or broker to make sure you have enough replacement coverage, so you can replace your home if it’s destroyed. Shop around for home insurance We’ve given you the average rates by state, but premiums vary by company. That’s why it’s vital to shop around. A good place to start is the Home Insurance Advisor. Our tool asks you a handful of questions about your situation and current home policy to help you identify potential problem spots. Once you figure out what you want for coverage, including deductible and liability insurance, get quotes from multiple home insurance companies. This will allow you an apples-to-apples comparison. Also, ask each insurer about discounts. Insurance companies offer discounts for bundling your home and auto and home security systems. See what discounts they have and how much that would reduce your premiums. Just as important as getting an inexpensive home insurance policy is finding a reputable company. Check out Insure’s Best Home Insurance Companies, where you can explore the ratings for 15 home insurance companies.