Can I switch home insurance companies in the middle of a policy?

Many homeowners wonder about switching home insurance companies in the middle of a policy, especially when seeking better coverage or lower rates. 

“You absolutely can switch home insurance companies mid-policy,” says Greg Martin, president at Think Safe Insurance. 

Martin continues, “It’s actually more common than people think. In most cases, your current insurer will give you a prorated refund for the unused portion of your premium.”

While it might seem complicated, the process is often more straightforward than you think. Understanding how to cancel your current policy, avoid coverage gaps and choose a new insurer can help you make a seamless transition. Here’s what you need to know about switching home insurance companies mid-policy.

How long does it take to switch home insurance?

Depending on your situation, finalizing a switch in your homeowners’ insurance policy may take a few hours or days. 

The bottleneck in the process is how long it takes for your new insurance policy to take effect. If your new insurer is speedy, coverage might go into effect within a few hours. However, with some insurers, seeing your new policy go into effect might take several days. 

Steps to switch home insurance mid-policy

If you want to switch your home insurance mid-policy, use the following steps as a guide:

1. Evaluate your coverage needs: You might need a new policy after a recent change in your house. For example, a home renovation or a newly installed pool might kickstart your need for a more robust policy. 
2. Research other insurance options: Start by looking for another insurance company that offers policies to suit your needs. If you are switching due to price concerns, getting multiple quotes from other insurance companies can help you find the most affordable option. 
3. Compare policies: After getting some quotes and landing on a potential policy, compare the details to your current policy. You may find that you don’t want to switch after all. For example, if you want to find a cheaper option but can’t achieve that without cutting back on your insurance coverage, you might decide to stick with your current policy. 
4. Start your new policy: After finding a policy with a new insurer, it’s time to start the new policy. Generally, you’ll make a payment to get the ball rolling. Coverage may take a few hours or several days to go into effect. 
5. Cancel your old policy: Once your new policy is in effect, you can cancel your old policy. 
6. Let your lender know: If you have a mortgage, you must let the lender know about any homeowner insurance switches. Usually, providing a document with the details of your new policy is sufficient. Your new insurer will send proof of insurance to your lender, as well.

What documents do I need to switch my homeowners insurance?

If you want to switch your insurance policy, it’s helpful to have several documents on hand. These include:

• Your existing insurance policy: Access to the fine print of your existing insurance policy can help you easily compare other potential insurance policies. 
• Personal information: You’ll need to share details about yourself, like your legal name, contact information, and marital status.
• Property attributes: The new insurer will want details about your home. For example, you might need to share proof of roofing repairs.  
• Inspection reports: Many insurance companies like to see a four-point inspection and a wind mitigation report in some areas to calculate your premiums. 
• Your new insurance policy: You’ll need to provide proof of insurance related to your new policy to your mortgage lender. 

Will there be penalties or fees for switching homeowners insurance policies?

Depending on your insurance company, there may or may not be a penalty for switching. 

Insurance companies base their rate on the expectation that you will keep the policy for the entire term. If you cancel earlier, especially very early in the term, the company may charge a penalty against your refund. This is called short-rating.

How to avoid coverage gaps when switching

“This is a big one because no one wants to deal with even a tiny lapse in coverage,” says Martin.

Having a lapse in coverage, even for a single day, can leave you vulnerable to potential risks and may even have consequences for future insurance applications. To avoid this, careful planning and attention to detail are essential.

Martin continues, “The key is timing. Make sure your new policy is active—also known as ‘bound’—before you cancel your current one. Once the new policy is in place, coordinate the cancellation date of your old policy so it lines up perfectly with the start date of the new one.”

Ensuring a smooth transition between policies provides peace of mind and eliminates the chance of being uninsured, which could lead to financial and legal issues in the event of an incident.

Martin further explains, “Here’s something people don’t always realize: Insurance cancellations take effect at 12:01 AM on the cancellation date. So, if your old policy ends on, say, July 1st, your new policy has to start on July 1st, too. If not, you’re technically uncovered for a day, and that’s a risk you don’t want to take.”

Understanding how cancellation times work and aligning the dates can prevent unexpected gaps in coverage. Proper coordination ensures continuous protection and complies with insurance requirements tied to loans or property ownership.

Benefits of switching home insurance mid-policy

If you are on the fence about making a switch, consider the following benefits:

• Get the right amount of coverage: When you make changes to your home, like installing a pool or renovating a portion of the house, you might need a different insurance policy to confirm everything new is covered. 
• Potential savings: If you find an insurance company offering a significantly lower rate, you could lock in savings going forward. 
• Better customer service: If you’ve had a bad experience with your current insurance company, you can leave them behind. 
• Bundling options: For homeowners who also purchase auto insurance, you can bundle your insurance needs when you switch. 

“Some people prefer to wait until their renewal date—especially if their homeowners insurance is escrowed with their mortgage. It can make things a little simpler, but if the benefits outweigh the hassle, switching mid-policy is totally worth considering,” says Martin.

Common pitfalls to avoid when switching homeowners insurance

When adjusting your insurance coverage, it’s helpful to avoid the following mistakes:

• Letting your coverage lapse: It’s essential to ensure you don’t cancel your existing coverage until your new policy is in effect. 
• Lowering your coverage amount: Although lowering your coverage in pursuit of lower rates may be tempting, this could ultimately hurt your wallet. Make sure you always carry the coverage you need. 
• Only looking at the price: A lower premium can help your budget. But it’s important to consider the insurer’s reputation to help avoid getting stuck in a bad situation. 

Related Articles