insure logo

Why you can trust Insure.com

quality icon

Quality Verified

At Insure.com, we are committed to providing honest and reliable information so that you can make the best financial decisions for you and your family. All of our content is written and reviewed by industry professionals and insurance experts. We maintain strict editorial independence from insurance companies to maintain our editorial integrity, so our recommendations are unbiased and are based on a comprehensive list of criteria.

Progressive provides the cheapest full coverage car insurance in New York at about $825 a year. Your specific rates may vary, but the average full coverage car insurance premium in New York is $168 per month, according to Insure.com’s 2022 rate analysis.

Car insurance is a legal requirement in most states, and New York is no exception. New York drivers are required to carry at least the minimum amount of liability coverage—$10,000 of personal property coverage per person, $25,000 for bodily injury per person and $50,000 for bodily injury per accident.

However, many drivers choose to purchase full coverage car insurance, which provides additional protection in the event of an accident.

What is full coverage car insurance in New York?

Full coverage car insurance includes bodily injury and property damage liability coverage, as well as comprehensive and collision coverage, according to the Insurance Information Institute (III). Collision insurance covers your vehicle if it’s damaged or destroyed in an accident, while comprehensive insurance provides protection against damage that is caused by something other than collisions such as weather or theft.

If you lease or finance your car in New York, your lender may ask you to purchase collision and comprehensive insurance beyond the state-mandated liability coverage. Every state except New Hampshire and Virginia requires drivers to get liability coverage, while comprehensive and collision coverage are optional. However, in Virginia, you have to pay an uninsured motorist fee of $500.

Average full coverage car insurance cost in New York

Full coverage insurance costs more than minimum liability insurance, but the extra cost is worth it for most drivers. Average cost of full coverage car insurance in New York is 20% more than the national average cost of full coverage insurance in the U.S.

There are different full coverage limits that a driver can purchase. However, Insure.com editors recommend that every driver should carry 100/300/100 coverage limits.

Cheapest full coverage car insurance rate in New York by company

Progressive offers the cheapest full coverage car insurance in New York an average of $825 per year. It’s 59% less expensive than the average full coverage car insurance cost in New York. The rates will vary based on factors such as your driving history, age, ZIP Code and the make and model of your car.

When shopping for auto insurance, compare rates from multiple companies to make sure you’re getting the best deal.

Below are the annual rates for car insurance from major insurance companies.

CompanyFull coverage insurance cost
Progressive$825
American Family$1,112
Geico$1,371
USAA$1,563
Erie Insurance$1,600
Allstate$1,749
State Farm$1,937
Travelers$2,580
Kemper Insurance$2,917
Mercury Insurance$4,551

Full coverage car insurance cost in New York by ZIP code

Full coverage car insurance premiums vary significantly by ZIP code. Insurance companies consider factors such as the crime rate in an area, the number of claims filed, types of claims filed to determine annual premiums. Below are the least and most expensive ZIP codes for full coverage car insurance.

Most expensive ZIP codes for car insurance in New York

Drivers living in the ZIP code 11212 pay the highest premiums at about $5,349 a year. ZIP codes with a higher number of car thefts or vandalism also tend to have higher car insurance rates.

Find below the most expensive ZIP codes for car insurance in New York.

ZIP codeFull coverage insurance cost
11212$5,349
11233$5,337
11213$5,329
11207$5,329
11234$5,323
11235$5,320
11210$5,295
11225$5,289
11239$5,260
11203$5,254

Least expensive ZIP codes for car insurance in New York

14830 ZIP code in New York has the cheapest full coverage auto insurance cost at an average price of $1,281 annually. Know the least expensive ZIP codes for car insurance in New York below.

ZIP codeFull coverage insurance cost
14830$1,281
14870$1,288
14821$1,297
14903$1,298
14894$1,302
14814$1,309
14905$1,311
14904$1,312
14901$1,313
14871$1,315

New York full coverage car insurance rate by age

Young drivers in New York tend to pay higher insurance rates than adult drivers because they are more likely to get into accidents and file claims on their insurance policy. A 16-year-old driver pays 266% more than a 40-year-old mature driver in New York, based on Insure.com’s analysis.

The table below shows full coverage car insurance rates for drivers of different ages:

Age groupFull coverage annual premiums
Teen drivers (age 16-19)$6,238
Young drivers (age 20-24)$3,331
Adult drivers (age 25-64)$2,070
Senior drivers (age 65+)$2,156

Read our Guide to car insurance for teens for more information

Car insurance rates in New York by driver history

Your driving history is one of the main factors insurers look at when considering insurance rates. If you are responsible for a car accident or get convicted of a driving infraction, your auto insurance premiums will likely go up. However, if you have a clean driving record, insurance companies see you as a low-risk driver and you are likely to get cheap full coverage car insurance.

Cheapest full coverage car insurance after a speeding ticket in New York

Getting a speeding ticket is never any fun. Not only will you have to pay a fine, but your insurance rates may go up. A single speeding ticket can increase your rates by 19% or $348 in New York, based on Insure.com data.

But if you’re looking for affordable coverage, below are some insurers that offer cheap full-coverage car insurance after a speeding ticket.

CompanyAverage annual premiumNew rate after incident% Increase$ Increase
Progressive$726$80911%$83
American Family$1,111$1,26614%$155
USAA$1,375$1,52611%$151
Geico$1,232$1,62332%$391
Erie$1,436$1,80526%$369
State Farm$1,645$1,80510%$160
Allstate$1,602$1,96823%$366
Travelers$2,355$2,71415%$359
Kemper$2,580$3,05118%$471
Mercury$4,157$5,13223%$975

Cheapest full coverage car insurance after an accident in New York

No one plans on getting into a car accident, but unfortunately, they happen. If you are in an accident and are at fault, you will probably see your car insurance premiums increase. However, this does not mean you can’t shop around to find the best rates.

Progressive offers the cheapest car insurance rates to drivers after an at-fault accident, at about $1163 a year. Below, you’ll see which companies have cheap car insurance for drivers with one accident on their record.

CompanyAverage annual premiumNew rate after incident% Increase$ Increase
Progressive$726$1,16360%$438
American Family$1,111$1,44530%$334
USAA$1,375$1,79330%$418
Geico$1,232$1,88853%$656
State Farm$1,645$1,96620%$321
Allstate$1,602$2,13633%$534
Erie$1,436$2,21054%$774
Travelers$2,355$2,80519%$451
Kemper$2,580$4,00255%$1,422
Mercury$4,157$5,72438%$1,567

Cheapest full coverage car insurance after a DUI conviction in New York

If you’ve recently been convicted of a DUI, you may wonder how it will affect your car insurance rates. Most insurers will view you as a high-risk driver and will charge you higher rates.

The table below shows the insurance companies offering cheap car insurance rates to drivers after a DUI conviction.

CompanyAverage annual premiumNew rate after incident% Increase$ Increase
Progressive$726$7595%$33
American Family$1,111$1,37524%$264
State Farm$1,645$1,80510%$160
USAA$1,375$1,97844%$603
Allstate$1,602$2,24740%$645
Erie$1,436$2,61482%$1,178
Travelers$2,355$2,81319%$458
Geico$1,232$3,357173%$2,126
Kemper$2,580$4,88089%$2,299
Mercury$4,157$5,35029%$1,194

When it comes to car insurance, everyone is always looking for ways to save. However, skimping on coverage to save a few dollars now could end up costing you dearly down the road.

Make sure you’re adequately protected and take into account your specific needs before buying an auto insurance policy.

Source:

Methodology

Insure.com gathered the quotes with the help of Quadrant Information Institute. We collected full coverage car insurance rates from major insurance companies for multiple ZIP codes across New York.

The full coverage rates are based on a sample driver profile of a 40-year-old man with a driving record and good credit score.

author image
Nupur Gambhir
Managing Editor

 
|
  

Nupur Gambhir is a content editor and licensed life, health, and disability insurance expert. She has extensive experience bringing brands to life and has built award-nominated campaigns for travel and tech. Her insurance expertise has been featured in Bloomberg News, Forbes Advisor, CNET, Fortune, Slate, Real Simple, Lifehacker, The Financial Gym, and the end-of-life planning service.