Does homeowners insurance cover code upgrades?

A standard homeowners insurance policy pays to repair your home the way it was, not the way current building code requires, so the added cost of code upgrades is generally not covered. Building code coverage, also sold as ordinance or law coverage, is the endorsement that pays that difference, and it is added to your policy for an extra premium.

You find out when your contractor pulls the permit. Your insurer approves the repair, the building department reviews the plans, and the upgrades it requires can add thousands of dollars the policy never agreed to cover. One homeowner with fire damage in four rooms was quoted $13,500 to rewire the rest of the house.

Most homeowners never learn the endorsement exists until they file a claim. If you own an older home, it costs nothing to check your policy for it now.

What is building code coverage?

Building code coverage is a supplemental endorsement you add to your homeowners policy that pays the cost of bringing your home up to current codes after a covered loss. It covers the difference between replacing what you had and building what the law now requires, and it comes at an additional cost.

You are not required to update your house every time a code changes. That protection ends once you rebuild, because current regulations apply to the work.

Building codes vary by location and often change after disasters. California wrote new codes following the 1906 San Francisco, 1933 Long Beach, 1971 San Fernando, and 1994 Northridge earthquakes, and new wildfire standards followed the 2003 and 2007 Southern California fires. Flood zone construction standards have been reset in many parts of the country.

What does building code coverage pay for?

Building code coverage pays for three separate costs that a standard policy leaves you to absorb, and homeowners are most often surprised by the second and third.

Here is what each one covers.

A real-life example of building code coverage in action

A fire in Juan and Cindy’s house caused significant damage to the kitchen, dining room, garage, and a second-story bedroom and bathroom. The house wasn’t destroyed, but it needed a major renovation and could not be occupied while the work was done.

Their home was older, and its wiring, outlets, and panel did not meet current code. Because of how extensive the repairs were, the building department required them to update the electrical throughout the entire house before it would issue a certificate of occupancy.

Their standard homeowners policy would only pay for electrical work in the damaged rooms. The quote to bring the rest of the house up to current electrical code was $13,500.

They had purchased a building code endorsement, which paid for the additional work minus a $500 deductible. Without it, that $13,500 would have been theirs to cover.

Why doesn’t a standard homeowners policy cover code upgrades?

A standard policy excludes code upgrades because it insures your house as it existed, not as a code official would require it to be built today. Your dwelling limit is set to replace what was there, and a law passed after your home was built is treated as a separate exposure.

Insurers treat the two as different costs — the fire damaged your kitchen, so the policy pays for the kitchen. The ordinance requiring a new electrical panel was imposed by the code, not caused by the fire.

This is also why the exclusion survives on a replacement cost policy. Replacement cost means your insurer pays without deducting depreciation, but it still pays to replace what you had.

When does building code coverage apply?

Building code coverage applies only when a covered loss triggers the code requirement, which is the single condition that determines whether you can claim it. It does not pay to bring your home up to code on an ordinary day.

Four things have to line up.

• The loss has to be covered. A code upgrade triggered by fire is claimable if fire is a covered peril. The same upgrade triggered by flood is not, because a standard policy excludes flood.
• The upgrade has to be required, not chosen. The building department has to mandate the work. Updating your kitchen while the walls are open is a renovation you pay for.
• The code has to be in force when the damage happens. The applicable code is the one on the books at the time of the loss, not the one in effect when the house was built.
• The work has to be part of the permitted repair. Codes are enforced at permitting, which is why a claim large enough to require a permit is the usual trigger.

Which code upgrades cost the most after a claim?

Electrical and roofing upgrades drive the highest code-related costs on most homeowners’ claims, because both are enforced across the whole system rather than just the damaged section. Juan and Cindy’s $13,500 electrical quote is a typical example of how that works.

Codes generally require an entire system to comply once you touch part of it, which turns a partial loss into a whole-house expense.

• Whole-house rewiring. Old wiring, outlets, and panels often cannot be patched under current code, so damage in a few rooms can require updating the entire house before occupancy is approved.
• Roof tear-off requirements. Many jurisdictions cap the number of roofing layers, so what would have been an overlay becomes a full tear-off and disposal.
• Ice barrier and underlayment. Colder climates require membrane and underlayment that older roofs were built without.
• Elevation in flood zones. Rebuilt homes can be required to meet current elevation requirements, which is among the most expensive triggers there is.
• Egress windows. A bedroom window that was legal in 1955 may fail current size and sill-height rules, turning a window replacement into framing work.
• Wind and seismic bracing. Hurricane straps, foundation anchoring, and seismic bracing get required in rebuilds where they were never installed.

What happens if repairs cost more than half your home’s value?

If your home sits in a flood zone and the cost to repair it reaches half the structure’s market value, your local officials can declare it substantially damaged, which requires the entire building to meet current floodplain standards before you can rebuild. This is known as FEMA’s 50% rule, and it is the most expensive code exposure a homeowner can face.

Federal regulation defines substantial damage as damage where the cost of restoring the structure to its condition before the loss would equal or exceed 50% of the structure’s market value. Cross that line and compliance can mean elevating the house, rebuilding with flood-resistant materials, adding flood venting, or demolishing and reconstructing it.

The rule applies to structures in Special Flood Hazard Areas within the more than 22,000 communities that participate in the National Flood Insurance Program. Some counties apply similar thresholds outside those zones under their own regulations.

Four details decide whether it hits you.

• 50% is the federal floor, not the ceiling. It is the NFIP minimum, and a state or community can adopt a stricter threshold such as 30% or 40%.
• Market value means the building, not the land. The figure comes from your county’s property assessment or a licensed appraiser, and land value stays out of it.
• Doing less work does not lower the number. Officials base the determination on the full cost to repair the structure to its pre-damage condition, even if you plan to do only part of the work or phase it over time.
• Some costs stay out of the calculation. Permits, plans, surveys, and outside improvements to the land such as landscaping, driveways, pools, and seawalls are excluded.

Your local government interprets and enforces this, so ask your building department for your threshold rather than assuming the federal minimum applies where you live.

Do you need building code protection?

Building code protection is most valuable if you own an older home, because the odds that the house no longer meets current code rise with every code cycle that passes. It is also worth carrying in areas where codes have changed substantially, including coastal and earthquake-prone regions.

Flood insurance customers have a partial backstop. FEMA provides flood insurance policyholders $30,000 of Increased Cost of Compliance coverage, which helps pay for elevation, though it is often not enough to cover the full cost.

These situations raise your exposure.

• The home predates the current code cycle by decades. Each cycle adds requirements the house does not meet.
• The house has original wiring or plumbing. These invite mandatory replacement once a permit is pulled.
• Your jurisdiction enforces aggressively. Some building departments require full compliance on modest permits and others do not, and this varies city by city.
• The home is in a high-wind, seismic, wildfire, or flood area. These codes change fastest and add the most expensive requirements.

How much building code coverage do you need?

The amount of building code coverage you need depends on your home’s value and your state, and the limits available vary widely. Homes valued over $500,000 may qualify for unlimited coverage, while some states cap it — Florida limits building code coverage to 30% of your dwelling coverage.

Policies differ on what they include to start with. Some homeowners policies include a small amount of building code coverage and others include none at all, which is why the declarations page matters more than the general rule.

The price varies by several factors, including the age of the property, according to Jones. Review your policy with your agent to confirm what you have and whether you should add more.

How to check and adjust your building code coverage

Work through these five steps in order.

• Read your declarations page first. Find out whether you have any building code or ordinance or law coverage, and at what limit.
• Ask your building department what triggers full compliance. The threshold and the enforcement posture are local, and they set your real exposure.
• Ask your agent to quote the next tier up. Compare the added premium against the shortfall a full-compliance rebuild would create.
• Check your dwelling limit at the same time. Where coverage is calculated as a percentage of dwelling coverage, an accurate limit is what makes the endorsement work.
• Reconfirm after a renovation. Permitted work resets parts of the house to current code and changes what a future rebuild would require.

Related Articles