Why you must insure all the cars you own

Why you should trust Insure.com

Quality Verified

At Insure.com, we are committed to providing honest and reliable information so that you can make the best financial decisions for you and your family. All of our content is written and reviewed by industry professionals and insurance experts. We maintain strict editorial independence from insurance companies to maintain editorial integrity, so our recommendations are unbiased and are based on a comprehensive list of criteria.

If you have only two drivers in your household, you may question the need for insuring a third vehicle that rarely gets used.

Most states require you to carry liability insurance on each car you drive, regardless of how often the vehicles are on the road. Generally, registered cars require insurance.

What’s the big deal about not insuring a car that rarely is used? The answer is simple. Liability insurance covers damage your cars might cause to others or their property. These days, the cost of repairs and medical expenses can add up quickly.

Key Takeaways

Most car insurance companies offer multi-car discounts and base their rates on a number of factors, including how many miles you drive each car annually.
You could save 10%-25% on your insurance by qualifying for a multi-car discount, according to Insure.com’s rate analysis.
By carrying a higher deductible, you can save money on your insurance if you have an older car.
Consider dropping comprehensive and collision coverage if one or more of your cars are more than five years old.

Accidents happen close to home

You may not drive your third car often or for great distances, but that doesn’t mean it won’t be in an accident. Studies repeatedly show that most car accidents occur close to home.

If your third car is sitting in the driveway or parked on the street, it still could be involved in a mishap. A tree could fall over during a storm and dent its roof. Your parked car could be broadsided by someone speeding down your street who then disappears.

If either of these things happened, you’d likely want comprehensive and collision insurance to help pay for the cost of repairing or replacing the vehicle. Comprehensive coverage pays for damage resulting from things other than car accidents. Collision pays to repair your own vehicle following an accident. For more information, see Insure.com’s Car insurance basics.

Here’s another scenario that explains why you need insurance for all your cars: One of the vehicles you drive is in the repair shop. You then use a car you rarely drive and accidentally run a red light. When a police officer stops you, he or she asks for proof that the car is insured. If it isn’t, you’ve got trouble.

Multicar discounts help lower premiums

If you don’t drive a car often, it probably won’t cost you that much extra to insure it. Most car insurance companies offer multicar discounts and base their rates on a number of factors, including how many miles you drive each car annually.

The only time you might not have to insure your extra car is if it isn’t operable. Check with your state department of motor vehicles.

Inform your agent of your move and find out your new car insurance rates.

Insure.com’s rate analysis shows that you can save up to 10% to 25%, on average, by qualifying for a multicar discount.

Ways to save on car insurance

If you own multiple cars, take steps to minimize your car insurance premiums, advises Amy Bach, executive director of the United Policyholders consumer group in San Francisco. She recommends that you:

Shop for the best rates. Get insurance quotes from different insurance companies. Be sure you’re comparing the costs of similar coverage plans; a deal isn’t a deal if it doesn’t provide adequate coverage.
Make sure you’re getting all the discounts to which you’re entitled. Often, car insurance companies offer a discount for insuring both your home and your vehicles with the insurer.
Carry a higher deductible on the oldest car and consider dropping comprehensive and collision coverage if one or more cars are older than five years. If a car is not worth the cost of repairing or you’re willing to live with a few dings and dents, you may not need the extra coverage.