How auto theft investigators work – and how to hire your own 

Why you can trust Insure.com

Quality Verified

At Insure.com, we are committed to providing the timely, accurate and expert information consumers need to make smart insurance decisions. All our content is written and reviewed by industry professionals and insurance experts. Our team carefully vets our rate data to ensure we only provide reliable and up-to-date insurance pricing. We follow the highest editorial standards. Our content is based solely on objective research and data gathering. We maintain strict editorial independence to ensure unbiased coverage of the insurance industry.

Auto theft spiked nationwide from 2019 through 2023, jumping more than 100% in many large cities and hitting over one million stolen cars in 2023. While thefts dropped in 2024 — falling to just under 851,000 — the problem hasn’t gone away. Certain states and metro areas continue to see high theft rates, and recovering a stolen vehicle can still be difficult.

Police departments juggle thousands of cases each year, which means some investigations move slowly. That’s one reason drivers sometimes bring in an auto theft investigator: someone who can dig deeper, help gather evidence for insurance, or track down leads that might otherwise be missed. These investigators use a mix of industry tools, theft-pattern knowledge, and fieldwork to figure out what happened to a missing car. Here’s a closer look at what they do — and how to hire one if you ever need that extra support.

What is an auto theft investigation expert and why do they matter in car theft claims?

An auto theft investigation expert is a specialist trained to examine a recovered vehicle and the evidence around it to understand how the theft happened. They look at the keys, locks, steering column, ignition, entry points, tow indicators, telematics, surveillance and timelines — along with your statement — to decide whether the theft is plausible.

Insurers rely on investigators with backgrounds in areas like locksmithing, fire investigation or law enforcement. Most work independently, though some insurers have in-house teams.

Their report carries a lot of weight. Insurance companies use their findings to determine whether a claim is legitimate, and if your claim is denied, any appeal often involves challenging their conclusions or hiring your own expert to provide a counteranalysis.

How to hire your own auto theft investigator

If your claim is stalled, denied or you feel the insurer’s investigator missed something important, you’re allowed to hire your own auto theft investigation expert. Here’s how to find a qualified investigator and what to look for.

• Start with certified professionals. Look for investigators who specialize in auto theft and have backgrounds in areas like law enforcement, fire investigation, forensic locksmithing or vehicle forensics. Many reputable experts belong to professional associations such as the International Association of Auto Theft Investigators (IAATI).
• Check their experience with insurance claims. Not all investigators work with policyholders. Choose someone who understands how insurers evaluate theft claims and who can provide reports or testimony that hold up during an appeal or dispute.
• Ask about their inspection process. A good investigator should be able to explain how they’ll examine the recovered vehicle, review documentation, analyze evidence and identify inconsistencies in the insurer’s report.
• Request references and sample reports. You want someone whose work is thorough, professional and credible. Seeing a sample report helps you understand the level of detail they provide and whether it can support your claim.
• Discuss fees upfront. Most auto theft investigators charge flat fees or hourly rates depending on the complexity of the case. Make sure you understand the cost structure before hiring.
• Share all documents and evidence. Give the investigator everything you have — police reports, photos, tow records, communication with your insurer and any details you provided in your statement. The more complete the picture, the stronger their findings will be.

Hiring your own expert can be helpful when the insurer’s conclusions don’t match what you know happened or when you need an independent voice to strengthen an appeal. A knowledgeable investigator can help clarify the facts, identify overlooked details and ensure your side of the story is fully represented.

How do insurance companies investigate a stolen car theft claim?

When a car is stolen, what happens next depends on whether it’s recovered. If it isn’t, the policyholder files a comprehensive claim for the loss. If the vehicle is found, the insurer inspects it to understand what happened — whether it was broken into, driven off, or if anything looks suspicious.

Recovered cars are usually towed to a salvage yard or secure lot. A claims adjuster may examine it first, and in some cases, an auto theft investigation expert is brought in.

They look for signs of forced entry or tampering and pay close attention to the steering column and ignition lock cylinder. These parts often reveal whether the right key was used, if the car was hot-wired or if there were signs of lockpicking. Their findings help the insurer determine how the theft occurred and whether the claim is valid.

What to read next

Can I insure a car that isn't in my name?

Do you need full coverage on a financed car?

Questions every driver should ask their car insurance agent

Minimum car insurance requirements by state

How to handle car insurance after divorce or separation

Non-owner car insurance: How to get car insurance if you don't own a car in 2025

Average SR-22 insurance cost in 2025

How does gap insurance work and do you need it?

A guide to veterans car insurance

Does car insurance cover hitting a deer?

Do you need a vehicle identification number for an insurance quote?

Everything you need to know about insuring two cars

What is full coverage car insurance?

What is liability auto insurance?

What is uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage?

Car warranties versus auto insurance

The secret life of your car's VIN

"Stacking" your UM/UIM auto insurance coverage

Show more

Our agents make it hassle-free to get the right quote.

Call (844) 814-8854

Ethan Available Now

Jack Available Now

Robbie Available Now

Ellie Available Now

Common claim investigation challenges and how to protect your theft claim

Insurance investigations can be slow and stressful, especially after a car theft. Insurers often require detailed documentation and consistent statements and may conduct interviews or inspections to rule out fraud. Missing information or conflicting details can delay the process or even lead to a denial.

Here’s how to protect your claim and keep it moving:

• Report the theft quickly. Contact your insurer right away and provide complete, accurate information.
• Keep organized records. Save police reports, emails, photos and all communication with the insurance company.
• Stay consistent in your statements. Even small discrepancies can slow the investigation or raise concerns.
• Ask for help if needed. An attorney or public adjuster can support you if the process becomes complicated or feels unfair.

Taking a proactive, organized approach gives you the best chance at a smooth and timely claim outcome.

Steps to take when your car is stolen

Filing a stolen car claim can feel overwhelming, but the process is straightforward once you know what to expect. Here’s how it typically works and what you’ll need to do along the way.

• File a police report. Report the theft as soon as you discover the car is missing. Share details like the make, model, color, license plate and anything that may help officers locate it.
• Notify your insurer. Contact your insurance company right after filing the police report. They’ll ask for the report number, vehicle information and details about where the car was last seen and who had access to it.
• Cooperate with the claim review. Your insurer will verify ownership, check for any outstanding loans and review the details of the theft. They may request documents, statements or additional information.
• If the car is recovered. Insurers usually wait a set amount of time to see if the vehicle turns up. If it’s found, they’ll assess the damage and pay for repairs based on your policy.
• If the car isn’t recovered. If the vehicle doesn’t resurface, the insurer will settle the claim based on the car’s actual cash value minus your deductible.

Being honest, responsive and organized throughout the process helps keep the claim on track and increases the chances of a smooth, timely payout.

How the right investigator can help your theft claim

Auto theft investigations can be complicated, and the process rarely moves as quickly as drivers would like. Whether you rely on your insurer’s investigator or decide to bring in your own expert, staying organized, communicating clearly and keeping good records can make a real difference in the outcome of your claim. 

If your theft claim hits a snag or you feel something was overlooked, you don’t have to navigate it alone — the right investigator or advocate can help you push for a fair, accurate resolution and give you a clearer path forward after a stressful experience.

Shivani Gite

Contributing Writer

 

|

 . .

Shivani Gite is a personal finance and insurance writer with a degree in journalism and mass communication. She is passionate about making insurance topics easy to understand for people and helping them make better financial decisions.