HO-3 vs. HO-5 Homeowners Insurance: Which Do You Need?

Why you can trust Insure.com

Quality Verified

At Insure.com, we are committed to providing the timely, accurate and expert information consumers need to make smart insurance decisions. All our content is written and reviewed by industry professionals and insurance experts. Our team carefully vets our rate data to ensure we only provide reliable and up-to-date insurance pricing. We follow the highest editorial standards. Our content is based solely on objective research and data gathering. We maintain strict editorial independence to ensure unbiased coverage of the insurance industry.

HO-3 and HO-5 are just industry codes for the two homeowners policies you’re most likely to be offered. An HO-3 is the standard policy that most people have, and an HO-5 is the upgraded version. Both cover your house, your stuff, your liability, and the cost of living elsewhere during repairs. The real difference comes down to one thing, which is how well each one protects your personal belongings.

With an HO-3, your belongings are only covered against a specific list of disasters, and claims are paid based on what your used items are worth today. With an HO-5, your belongings are covered against almost everything, and you’re paid enough to actually buy new replacements. That single difference is what most of this decision turns on.

“The main difference between an HO-3 and an HO-5 home insurance policy is that an HO-5 policy is more comprehensive for your personal possessions,” says Loretta Worters, vice president of media relations for the Insurance Information Institute, an insurance industry association.

Key Takeaways

HO-3 is the most common homeowners policy. It covers your home’s structure for all perils but only covers personal belongings for named perils.
HO-5 covers both your home and personal belongings against all perils, providing broader protection with fewer restrictions.
HO-5 pays out personal property claims at replacement cost. HO-3 typically pays actual cash value unless you add an endorsement.
HO-5 costs more but is worth considering if you have a higher-value home or expensive belongings.

What are HO-3 and HO-5 homeowners insurance?

Both are standard homeowners policies that cover four things, which are your home’s structure, your personal belongings, your liability if someone is hurt or their property is damaged, and your living expenses if you’re forced out during repairs. The HO-3, sometimes called a special form policy, is the most commonly sold homeowners policy in the country, according to the National Association of Insurance Commissioners.

The HO-5, or comprehensive form policy, covers all the same things but goes further on your belongings. As Loretta Worters of the Insurance Information Institute puts it, the main difference is that an HO-5 is more comprehensive when it comes to your personal possessions.

Before the comparison makes sense, two pieces of insurance shorthand are worth knowing.

Named perils vs. open perils. A named perils policy only covers the specific disasters it lists, like fire or theft, and anything not on the list isn’t covered. An open perils policy flips that around and covers everything except a short list of stated exclusions.
Actual cash value vs. replacement cost. Actual cash value pays what your item is worth today, after years of wear have lowered its value. Replacement cost pays enough to buy a new version of similar quality.

What is the difference between HO-3 and HO-5 homeowners insurance?

The main difference between HO-3 and HO-5 is how they cover your personal belongings. An HO-3 covers your belongings only for named perils and pays their depreciated value. An HO-5 covers your belongings for open perils and pays replacement cost, which makes it the broader and more protective of the two. For your home’s structure, the two policies work the same way.

Feature	HO-3	HO-5
Home’s structure	All risks except stated exclusions	All risks except stated exclusions
Personal belongings	Only the risks named in the policy	All risks except stated exclusions
How claims are paid	Replacement cost for the home, depreciated value for belongings	Replacement cost for the home and belongings
Cost	Usually cheaper	Usually a bit more
Best for	Most homeowners	Higher-value homes and belongings

How does HO-5 coverage go further than HO-3?

The biggest gap is in how your belongings are protected, but a few other perks come with an HO-5 too. Because an HO-5 covers your belongings for open perils, the burden falls on the insurer to prove a loss isn’t covered, rather than on you to prove it is.

Beyond that core difference, an HO-5 often includes extras that usually cost extra on an HO-3.

Higher payouts on valuables. HO-5 policies tend to offer more generous coverage for things like jewelry and watches.
Higher liability and medical limits. You often get more protection if someone is injured on your property.
Built-in replacement cost on belongings. An HO-3 pays depreciated value unless you buy an add-on, while an HO-5 includes replacement cost automatically.
Occasional bonus coverages. Some HO-5 policies cover things like water backup or sump pump overflow that a standard HO-3 leaves out.

Some insurers also fold extended or guaranteed replacement cost into an HO-5, which pays above your coverage limit if rebuilding costs run high. Amica’s Platinum Choice HO-5, for example, adds up to 30% above your limit to repair or rebuild, something typically sold only as an add-on with an HO-3.

How the two policies pay out, in real examples

The clearest way to see the difference is to watch how each one handles the same claim.

Say thieves steal your five-year-old television. An HO-5 reimburses you for the full cost of a similar new TV at today’s prices. An HO-3 pays only the depreciated value of the old one, unless you added replacement cost coverage.

Or picture a fire that destroys a ten-year-old couch. As Worters explains, actual cash value might get you around $500 for that couch, but with full replacement cost, a new couch of similar quality could run $5,000, and the insurance would cover it.

The gap shows up most with expensive items. If a fire ruins a costly piece of jewelry, an HO-3 may not cover its full value without a specific add-on, while an HO-5’s higher limits are more likely to cover the whole thing.

What do HO-3 and HO-5 policies exclude?

Both policies exclude several of the same things, and no policy covers everything. Every insurer sets its own exclusions, so reading your policy and asking your agent what’s left out matters. The exclusions below are fairly standard, and a “yes” means the loss is generally not covered.

Exclusion	HO-3	HO-5
Earthquake	Yes	Yes
Flood	Yes	Yes
Wear and tear	Yes	Yes
Mold, fungus, and rot	Yes	Yes
Mice, insects, and other pests	Yes	Yes
Long-term water seepage	Yes	Yes
Sewer backup	Yes	No
Expensive jewelry and valuables	Yes	No

Floods and earthquakes are excluded from both, so if you’re at risk for either, you’ll need a separate policy no matter which one you choose.

How much more does an HO-5 cost than an HO-3?

An HO-5 costs about $127 more per year than an HO-3, according to the National Association of Insurance Commissioners. That’s roughly $10 a month for coverage that protects your belongings against far more risks and pays to replace them new, which is why the upgrade often costs less than people expect.

What you actually pay comes down to a few factors.

Your home’s value and rebuild cost. A higher-value home shows a bigger dollar gap between the two policies, since there’s more to insure.
Your location and deductible. The same risks that drive any premium apply here too.
Your claims history. Past claims can raise the price of either policy.
Your insurer. Pricing varies widely, so quote both policy types from the same company to see your real difference.

Which policy is right for you, HO-3 or HO-5?

For most homeowners an HO-3 is enough, while an HO-5 makes the most sense for higher-value homes and expensive belongings. The decision usually comes down to what you own and how small the price difference turns out to be for you. A quick gut check: picture a total loss and ask whether being paid the depreciated value of your belongings would leave you short.

When an HO-3 makes sense

An HO-3 is the right fit for most people, and it’s likely the policy you already have. As Alaina Hixson of The Churchill Agency puts it, most homeowners already carry an HO-3 and don’t need to upgrade. An HO-3 tends to make sense if:

You don’t own many high-value belongings, or much of your furniture is hand-me-down.
You want lower premiums and are comfortable with standard coverage.
You’d rather add endorsements for specific gaps, like replacement cost on belongings or extra jewelry coverage, and pay only for what you need.

When an HO-5 makes sense

An HO-5 is worth considering if you own a higher-value home or belongings that would be expensive to replace all at once. Because it covers everything except stated exclusions, the insurer has to prove a loss isn’t covered rather than you having to prove it is, which removes a lot of friction from a big claim. An HO-5 is often a fit if:

Your home is valued above $750,000, the range Hixson says these policies generally target.
You want the broadest protection available, with higher limits and fewer restrictions.
You’d rather have replacement cost and valuables coverage built in than bolt it on piece by piece.

One thing to know before you count on an HO-5: not everyone qualifies, and not every insurer offers one. These policies set stricter standards for a home to qualify, so you may need to shop around or update your home first. If you’re unsure which fits, an insurance agent can review your needs and point you to the right coverage.

Frequently asked questions

Is HO-5 insurance better than HO-3 insurance?

An HO-5 offers stronger protection for most homeowners, since it covers your belongings for open perils and pays claims at replacement cost instead of depreciated value. That said, “better” depends on your situation. If you don’t own much of high value, an HO-3 with a few endorsements can give you similar protection for less. The upgrade pays off most when you have expensive belongings or a higher-value home where a depreciated payout would leave you well short.

Why is HO-5 insurance more expensive?

An HO-5 covers more risks and excludes fewer, so the insurer takes on greater risk, and that gets built into your premium. It also pays replacement cost on belongings rather than their depreciated value, which means larger payouts on claims. The difference is smaller than most people expect, though, averaging about $127 more a year.

Does an HO-3 or HO-5 cover floods?

Neither one covers floods. Both also exclude earthquakes, so you’ll need separate coverage for either risk no matter which policy you carry. Flood coverage comes through a separate policy, usually from the National Flood Insurance Program or a private insurer, and earthquake coverage is typically sold as its own policy or endorsement. If you’re in a flood- or quake-prone area, it’s worth lining up that coverage before you need it.

What our expert says

Loretta WortersVice president of media relations for the Insurance Information Institute

“The main difference between an HO-3 and an HO-5 home insurance policy is that an HO-5 policy is more comprehensive for your personal possessions.”

Alisha Ambre

Alisha Ambre holds a Bachelor of Arts with honours in English Literature and Media Studies. She focuses on crafting clear, engaging content that makes complex information feel practical and approachable for everyday readers. When she’s not writing, she’s likely on the volleyball court or immersed in a good video game.

On this page