Home Car insurance Coverage Don’t let other people drive your car Don’t let other people drive your car Written by: Barbara Marquand | Reviewed by: Michelle Megna Michelle Megna Michelle, the former editorial director, insurance, at QuinStreet, is a writer, editor and expert on car insurance and personal finance. Prior to joining QuinStreet, she reported and edited articles on technology, lifestyle, education and government for magazines, websites and major newspapers, including the New York Daily News. | Posted on December 13, 2012 Why you should trust Insure.com Quality Verified At Insure.com, we are committed to providing honest and reliable information so that you can make the best financial decisions for you and your family. All of our content is written and reviewed by industry professionals and insurance experts. We maintain strict editorial independence from insurance companies to maintain editorial integrity, so our recommendations are unbiased and are based on a comprehensive list of criteria. You may have a problem when your no-good, beer-swilling brother-in-law swipes your car keys without your permission. Or your 14-year-old goes for a joyride. Or your neighbor borrows your car with your blessing and then lets his goofy nephew drive it. Hope and pray these people don’t get in accidents, because car insurance coverage can be tricky at best and nonexistent at worst in cases like these. You could be on the hook not only for the damage to your own car but the damage the driver causes others. And if you live in a no-fault state, personal injury protection for the driver could be in jeopardy. Car insurance policies generally cover you and the licensed drivers in your household who are listed on the policy and any other licensed driver to whom you give occasional permission to drive the car. Details can vary by policy or state law, but in general, when someone drives your car without your permission, coverage “depends on whether it’s going to be classified as a theft or unauthorized use,” says CarInsurance.com consumer analyst Penny Gusner. If your car is stolen, then any damage to your vehicle would be covered under comprehensive insurance, an optional form of coverage. If you carry only liability insurance, the damage to your car isn’t covered at all. Even if the thief has his own car insurance coverage, it will not cover his criminal actions. Meanwhile, your insurance will not cover the thief’s liability. The thief could be sued for any damage or injuries he causes. Stolen or taken without permission? The distinction between theft and unauthorized use is murky. You might tell your insurer that the car was stolen, Gusner says, but that becomes questionable if the person who took the car was a family member or friend who had ready access to the keys. “It’s a gray area,” she says. Say, for instance, your brother-in-law, who has a criminal record, gets drunk, takes the keys off the counter and crashes the car, injuring others. Generally, your car insurance would not provide coverage if you say you didn’t give him permission to drive the car. Saying the car was stolen doesn’t get you completely off the hook, either, even if you go so far as to press charges against him. “Potentially someone could sue you for negligence for leaving the keys out,” says Benny Agosto Jr., a partner at Abraham, Watkins, Nichols, Sorrels, Agosto & Friend, a personal injury law firm in Houston. In cases like these involving family members, car owners typically say the borrowers had their permission to drive, Agosto says. Your insurance company then has a duty to defend you in a lawsuit, but it reserves the right not to pay the damages if it finds you were negligent. However, Agosto says, insurance companies often agree to pay a claims settlement in order to avoid getting sued by policyholders for bad faith. Joyriding brings grief Then there’s the 14-year-old who takes the car for a joyride and causes a wreck. “That’s a nightmare there,” Agosto says. You can’t legally give your unlicensed kid permission to drive. And even though your child caused the damage — not you — you’re still responsible as the parent, he adds. “When a child swipes the keys, it opens a can of worms,” Gusner says. Court sides with auto insurance companies A few years ago, the Michigan Supreme Court weighed in on whether a person injured while driving a car against the wishes of the owner could receive Personal Injury Protection (PIP) benefits under the car owner’s policy. Michigan requires car owners to carry PIP insurance, which covers injuries to the driver and passengers, regardless of who caused the accident. Two cases were consolidated for the court’s ruling. In one, an unlicensed husband with three drunk driving convictions drove his wife’s car without permission, got in a wreck and was seriously injured. The man was specifically excluded on his wife’s policy. The hospital and rehabilitation center where he was treated sought PIP benefits from Progressive Marathon Insurance Co., his wife’s insurer, but the company denied the claim. In the other case, a father let his son’s girlfriend use his car but expressly prohibited his unlicensed son from driving it. Later that night, the son drank and asked for the keys. The girlfriend initially refused, but then relented, and the son crashed into a tree. farm bureau mutual insurance Co. of Michigan, the father’s insurer, denied PIP benefits for the son. In both cases, the health care providers sued the auto insurance companies in order to try to get PIP benefits paid. In a July 31 ruling, Michigan’s high court sided with the insurance companies and said that any person who takes a car unlawfully, including a family member who takes the car for a joyride, is excluded from receiving PIP benefits. Gusner has this advice for parents: “Lock up the keys if you have teenagers.” Agosto agrees: “All my car keys are in my safe in a locked closet in my bedroom, which is locked — not because I have bad kids, but because kids get together with other kids,” he says. “Leaving the keys out is like leaving out a loaded gun.” QuickTake Everything you need to know about insuring two cars Do you need the VIN number for the insurance quote? Does car insurance cover hitting a deer? Non-owner car insurance: How to get car insurance if you don't own a car Minimum car insurance requirements by state What is Full Coverage Car Insurance? Can I insure a car that isn't in my name? What is liability auto insurance? 15 things you didn't know your car and home insurance policies cover How auto theft investigators work - and how to hire your own What is uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage? Car warranties versus auto insurance How Does Gap Insurance Work and Do You Need it? Do you need full coverage on a financed car Veterans and military guide to insurance The secret life of your car's VIN "Stacking" your UM/UIM auto insurance coverage 5 questions to ask your car insurance agent 10 things that aren’t illegal but should be SR-22 insurance: What is it and how does it work? Auto insurance: How to make sure you’re not underinsured How to cut your car insurance bill in half 12 things you don't know about car insurance that could cost you Untangling your insurance during a separation or divorce My wife was half asleep when she went out to scrape snow and ice off her car. She used a snow shovel, not realizing she picked up the one with the sharp metal blade at the end, so she scratched the car all over. Will her car insurance cover the damage? My car was rear-ended and totaled but it was paid out by my insurance company and I am left with a balance on my car. Can I make a claim with the other drivers insurance company to pay the balance? As I was backing out of the driveway I hit a parked car that was parked beside the curb in the street causing what looked like mild damage. My vehicle had no damage. Will I have to pay a deductible? Taking the slow lane by storm: Insurance for low-speed vehicles Car insurance for blind drivers (you heard that right) Would I lie to you about car insurance? Only if it pays off Insuring your tricked-out, souped-up car See more > In case you missed it Best Car Insurance Companies of 2023 Car insurance rates by state: The most expensive and cheapest states for car ins... What is Full Coverage Car Insurance? How much does car insurance cost for seniors? A complete guide to adding a teenager to your car insurance policy What to do after a car accident that’s not your fault Total warfare: What to do when your auto insurer totals your car Car insurance claims: Who gets the claims check? Buying and insuring a used car: Most and least expensive models to insure in 202... The Best Car Insurance for Bad Credit of 2021 The best car insurance companies for speeding tickets Car insurance after a DUI Guide to Car Insurance Discounts Proper insurance coverage for college-bound children How to read actually understand your auto insurance policy Car Insurance Companies New driver insurance grace period: What you need to know How much do insurance agents make Autonomous cars: 5 delightful and 5 distressing things Busted! Part 1: How insurance companies spot bogus claims Insurance options for rideshare drivers 10 things that are illegal but shouldn’t be 1/1 On this page Stolen or taken without permission?Joyriding brings griefCourt sides with auto insurance companies Get instant quotes now ! Please enter valid zip Get Quotes